Why do some no-account swaps still ask for an email or a refund address

05 September 2026

Because the swap needs a way to reach you if something goes wrong, and an email or refund address is the only contact method that works when you never registered. The request is not part of an identity check; it is a failure-handling mechanism.

A no-account swap is built on the assumption that you will not identify yourself. The service never asks for your name, your ID, or your wallet's ownership proof. But a trade can fail after the service has received your coins. The network can be congested, the receiving chain can reject a transaction, or a token can be sent to an address that does not support it. When that happens, the service has your funds and no way to give them back. It needs a destination.

The email address serves that purpose. The service can write to you with instructions, a new deposit address, or a request to pick a different receiving network. It does not verify that the address belongs to you. It does not check that you are human. It only needs a place to send a message that you might read.

The refund address is more direct. If the swap cannot complete, the service sends the original coins back to that address. The address is the return path. It may be a wallet you control, or it may be a temporary address you generated for the purpose. The service does not care who owns it; it cares that the coins have somewhere to go instead of sitting in its custody forever.

Some services ask for both. Some ask for only one. Some ask for neither and instead hold the funds until you contact them through a support ticket, which is a worse experience for everyone involved. The services that ask are not being nosy. They are reducing the chance that your funds become unreturnable.

There is a common misunderstanding that the email is used for marketing or for building a profile. That can happen, but it is not the reason the field exists. The field exists because a swap without a refund path is a swap that can lose your money permanently. A service that asks for an email is not necessarily a service that tracks you. A service that asks for nothing may simply be accepting the risk that some trades will end in lost funds.

You can often skip the field. Many services allow you to leave it blank and proceed, with a warning that you will have no way to recover funds if the trade fails. That is the honest trade-off. The field is optional because the service knows you may not want to give it. But if you skip it, you are the one absorbing the failure risk.

A refund address is different. It is usually required, because it is the mechanism by which the service returns your coins. Without it, the service has no legal or technical way to complete a refund. It cannot guess where your coins came from. The blockchain does not tell it. The address you sent from is visible, but the service cannot be certain that you still control it, and sending coins back to a source address can fail if that address is a contract or a temporary input.

The practical advice is straightforward. If a swap asks for an email, you can use a disposable address or leave it blank if the service allows it. If a swap asks for a refund address, give it one you control. The request is not a sign of surveillance. It is a sign that the service has thought about what happens when a trade goes wrong.

If you want to understand how the service sees the rest of your activity, the hub page "Swapping crypto without an account" covers what information a swap site can observe when you never make an account. That page is the natural next read if you are weighing how much to trust a particular service.

Back to sui & aptos